1 pointWatson took 2nd to Barker in 2000. I don't think many of the above qualify. The criteria mentioned was best first year or 2nd year of wrestling. Not best wrestlers who had no youth wrestling. For example, I specifically mentioned Buchanan's 2nd year of wrestling where he took 2nd at State, not his 3rd and 4th years of wrestling where he took 3rd and 1st.